Measurement Books Reviewed
Jim Sterne's Social Media Metrics is easy to read and covers virtually every social media metric.
Shiv Singh's Social Media Marketing for Dummies is a great primer for people who want to do social media right.
Summary: If you’re trying to navigate into the world of social media, start with Shiv Singh's book. If you’re trying to measure the effectiveness of those efforts, Jim Sterne's is the better bet.
Book Reviews by Katie Delahaye Paine
Social Media Metrics: How to Measure and Optimize Your Marketing Investment
by Jim Sterne, Foreword by David Meerman Scott, ISBN 978-0-470-58378-4, Wiley, 2010, $24.95.
Buy Social Media Metrics from Wiley now.
Jim Sterne has written by far the most comprehensive book yet on how to measure social media, and he’s written it in a delightful, easy-to-read, conversational tone that has you grinning frequently and occasionally LOL. Social Media Metrics covers virtually every metric ever discussed, and most of the tools to measure them.
He starts with setting measurable goals and then moves on to identifying reach, sentiment, influence, and all those other concepts that are on everyone’s lips these days. Sterne gives solid practical advice including websites, tools, and sources for virtually every metric that he recommends.
Anyone using, or contemplating using, automated sentiment analysis must read his chapter on the topic. It is brutal, honest, and very revealing. Stern also answers the oft-asked question: "How do I convince my colleagues to measure social media?" And, lest you think this is only for the newbies, Sterne includes some seriously thought-provoking discussion on the future of social media metrics.
Now, to be honest, Jim and I agree on almost everything, and he quotes me frequently throughout the book, so it’s hardly surprising that I love it.
But the book does have a flaw. It is the same problem that most people associate with social media: It’s a torrent of information. I came away from it knowing a whole lot more about how to measure social media, but feeling a bit overwhelmed and wanting to go to a Caribbean island named “Measurenotland.” But, given the economic and psychological conditions of most businesses these days, you’ll want to read this book now!
Social Media Marketing for Dummies
by Shiv Singh, ISBN 978-0-470-28934-1, Wiley, 2009, paperback, $24.99.
Buy Social Media Marketing for Dummies from Wiley now.
I love the “...for Dummies” series and dove into this book with high expectations. When I see “Learn to measure the results of your efforts!” on the cover of a book, how can I not open it, salivating with anticipation?
This book is a great primer for people wanting to understand how to do social media right. Singh calls his approach Social Influence Marketing and his recommendations are spot on.
He walks the reader carefully through the minefield of social media, with good solid advice at almost every step of the way. Great, well-thought-out stuff on planning, communicating, reaching out to, and involving customers and employees in your social media efforts.
Where I really have a problem is with Singh's measurement recommendations. He’s very big on measuring activity, like Facebook fans, and Twitter followers, and very weak on tying those activities to any business goals. He does acknowledge that it is important to marry your activity metrics to marketing and business objectives, but leaves the reader in the lurch as to how to actually accomplish this.
He also accepts automated sentiment analysis as a given, wholeheartedly endorsing specific vendors with no acknowledgement of the weaknesses inherent in the systems he discusses. Nor does he give any indication of the costs of these systems, which could certainly be far beyond most dummies' budgets.
One other caution: Many of the numbers are out of date. So you might want to update his facts and figures before you use the numbers he quotes in your presentation to upper management. This is the essential problem of printed text in a fast-evolving world. His figures for Facebook for example, are off by some 35 million visitors (and will be even more so by the time you read this).
(In the interest of transparency, I have my own measurement book, Measuring Public Relationships: The Data-Driven Communicator's Guide to Success, on the marker, and a second edition due out later this year. And I’m quoted a lot in Jim Sterne's book. --KDP) 